GOLD COAST CAPITAL MANAGEMENT, LLC
Portfolio Decisions

Too Much Company Stock? How to Balance Diversification and TaxesToo Much Company
Stock? How to
Balance Diversification
and Taxes

By Dragan Mark Filipovic, CFA Founder and Chief Investment Officer

Company stock can become a large part of your wealth through equity compensation, an employee purchase plan or years of strong performance. Deciding what to do with it can feel difficult: selling may create taxes, while keeping it preserves exposure to a company you know well.

Start by assessing how much of your financial life depends on that company. The answer includes the shares you own and may also include your salary, bonus and future compensation.

Familiarity with your employer and pride in its success can make selling feel disloyal or premature. A useful question is whether you would choose the same exposure today if you were investing the equivalent amount in cash. That can help separate confidence in the business from the risk your personal goals can absorb.

Measure the exposure before choosing a sale amount

Add up vested shares across accounts, including shares held outside your main brokerage account. Review unvested awards separately because they have conditions and are not the same as cash or freely tradable investments. Check whether funds you own add further exposure to the company or its industry.

For example, an investor with $300,000 of employer stock and $700,000 of other investments has 30% of that investment portfolio in one company. A 40% decline in the employer stock would reduce the $1 million portfolio by $120,000, or 12%, if everything else remained unchanged. Salary and future awards could also become less secure during a business downturn.

This hypothetical example is not a suggested concentration limit. It shows why a company-specific risk can matter even when the rest of the portfolio is diversified.

Evaluate risk alongside the tax cost

For taxable shares, review cost basis, holding periods, unrealized gains or losses and the type of award involved. Restricted stock units, employee stock purchase plans and stock options do not all have the same tax treatment. Part of your shares’ value may already have been taxed as compensation, even though you have not sold the shares. Confirm the records with your tax professional.

A tax bill is a real cost. So is continuing to expose a large share of your wealth to one company’s future. Avoid treating either consideration as the only one that matters.

Ask how a decline would affect your retirement date, a planned purchase or your ability to leave the company. Money needed for an important near-term goal may warrant a different decision from money that can remain invested for many years.

Discuss your company-stock exposure in a Portfolio Second Opinion

Compare an immediate reduction with a staged approach

Selling a larger amount can reduce concentration sooner but may realize more gains in one year. A staged approach may spread sales over time, but it leaves you exposed to the stock while the plan is carried out. The price may fall before later sales occur.

Directing new savings elsewhere can help reduce reliance on the company, although it may be too slow when the existing position is large. Where charitable giving is already a goal, appreciated shares may be worth discussing with tax and legal professionals. Giving assets away is not a substitute for funding your own needs.

The appropriate approach depends on your circumstances. There is no universal percentage of company stock that is suitable for every investor.

Check restrictions before placing trades

Employees and insiders may face trading windows, preclearance requirements or other restrictions. Possessing material nonpublic information can also affect whether trading is permitted. Confirm the rules with your company’s compliance team and legal counsel; do not treat an investment plan as authorization to trade.

Any use of a formal trading plan requires appropriate specialist guidance. The investment objective and the legal ability to execute a sale must be evaluated together.

Give the proceeds a role in the portfolio

Diversification is incomplete if sale proceeds simply drift into another concentrated position. Decide how the money will support cash needs and the target mix of investments across your accounts.

Also plan for future vesting or purchases. A one-time sale may reduce today’s exposure while new awards rebuild it. A repeatable review process can help keep those decisions connected to your goals, rather than dependent on the latest share price.

Review the whole picture

Before deciding what to change, gather:

  • The value of company shares across accounts and upcoming vesting dates.
  • Cost basis, holding periods and the type of equity award.
  • Applicable trading restrictions and preclearance requirements.
  • The purchases, retirement plans or other goals a substantial decline could affect.

Bring that picture to a Gold Coast Portfolio Second Opinion. We can discuss how much of your investment risk comes from company stock, how a reduction would affect your broader portfolio and what tax or trading questions need specialist input. Concentrated holdings are considered within your ongoing wealth management relationship.

Your review is with Dragan Mark Filipovic, CFA, Gold Coast’s founder and Chief Investment Officer. If you
become a client, the same investment professional personally manages the accounts you entrust to Gold Coast.

Do not currently have an advisor? Request a Complimentary Portfolio Review.
Both reviews are complimentary, with no obligation to become a client.

Further Reading

Continue Reading

Explore more insights on investing, portfolio management,
retirement planning and working with a financial advisor.